• 5 Posts
  • 1.18K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle

  • The math on protests has changed

    I’m not saying don’t protest. I’m saying the math has changed. I look at it like a thermodynamics problem. How much energy goes in and what do we get out? A protest takes so much organization. People have to travel, take time off, risk their health, risk arrest. And the reward lately has been almost nothing. This isn’t the 70s anymore where seeing a million people marching would be shocking and attention grabbing. I can get 1 million people out to check out a girls butthole. It’s just not the same world.

    Here’s the thing that doesn’t make sense to me. If you think you can get people to physicaly show up to a protest then it only makes sense it should be easier to rally them digitally. If you don’t think you can do it online but you think you can do it in the street then you’re not thinking logically. It’s way less effort and a better payoff to secure an online presence and watch pages shift then to go stand in a street for a few hours and go home.

    And without that presence you can’t even say what the protest is about. The opposition will say it for you. Ask yourself why patriot front and others are gaining cultural significants with a van full of racists. They secured the online channels first. So when they show up they control the messaging, and that is proven to work at changing peoples opinions. It is bad out there. Facebook, twitter and even reddit now that everybody left. The racism, the sexism, the hate. It’s growing because its unchecked.

    We know groups like heritage foundation and TPUSA and random billionaires have the time and resources. They have research like cambridge analytica and more. Its crazy to think the only people that got radicalized was MAGA. The left fell for the propaganda too. We left the public squares. We convinced each other to leave the technology and spaces we used to control, and then we tried to fight back in ways that are high cost and low reward.

    So I think we need to change what we’re doing. Not forever, just for now. Get back out there and have fun with it. Argue, troll, learn the tactics they’ve been using on us and return fire. The algorithms arent a light switch. Its not on for MAGA and off for the left. It’s about engagement, and guess what that means. People on the left see more right posts and vice versa. Thats a great starting point. Real people, no fake accounts, just coordinated.

    Lemmy should be where we build the networks. Where’s our libs of tiktok moment? Where’s our 4chan moment where we find a flag by clouds and flights? Something is lacking on the left and we need to fix it.

    Then, when we’ve built it back up, we protest. But without doing the ground work first its all cost low reward.



  • Ok and I’ve try to see any of these protests affect change. When you factor in the cost it just doesn’t make sense. If anything i really believe protest are organized by the opposition. Like how they did back in the day to actually create anger towards the protestors.

    The cost benefits do not add up. When pressed to show any, I often hear responses like yours where it’s very loose and vague. I think people love the idea of a protest and honestly it’s just a sunk cost fallacy right now.

    It is much more effective and powerful to use digital spaces. But it need networks. To build the networks you need people to be active and I have only seen leftist convincing each other to log off and be less active online and to instead to these high risk activities like showing up to get their heads caved in by police meanwhile the opposition is using all the digital spaces that were abandoned to spread hate towards the protesters.

    Trying to protest on today’s age without securing the channels we use to communicate is foolish. I think given what we know about the money behind a lot of modern things that it isn’t crazy to suggest that the left as a whole may have been led towards high cost low rewards activities to keep us occupied and out of the way.



  • How, how the fuck does this even work. I don’t fucking understand why people will go to great lengths to show up like this in a street in some random city with a goal like “reduce male violence”

    Have you guys been on Facebook lately? They’re increasing a culture of male violence one bobs burger group at a time. You heard that right. Because the people who actually are using the data, and their wealth know that to get action you need to affect culture. You don’t affect jack fucking shit standing in the god damn fucking cold. You affect culture by slowly over time by spreading your culture as far as you can see while surpression the culture that is in opposition to yours. In a digital age when eye balls and ears are online, you go to the places people see. Fuck me i can flood a single page with my culture if I really wanted to and beat get a much further reach and affect in a couple weeks than this thousand or so people. Imagine what these people could do in a month if they instead went to the hate groups and flooded it with content to spread information and used mematic spread to grow and attract more people. You can even do it in your pajama with a coffee. But fuck no, instead drive 150km to so random city and stand around for 8hrs



  • I wrote here first so I’ll just link to it here.

    But yea you’re charitable understanding is right. I don’t think the average right winger has some logical or morally correct or deep understanding. But they have been exposed to more stories and views and frames on these events.

    I know people have experienced what I’m about to say, we all have. You go to have a conversation and you start saying some topics and all of a sudden you’re hearing things from the right winger you had no idea was even happening. They know the points on the left but the people on the left aren’t aware of their points. I don’t just mean “abortions are murder” what I mean is stuff like “Trump just moved 2000 soldiers to Botswana after Biden failed attempt at securing the region back in 2008 operation freedoms puppies that he spearheaded” and you look it up and the details are accurate, the frame is hack but the details are accurate.

    https://lemmy.world/comment/26784901




  • It’s like you people on the left are just brainwashed. Yes bots are a part of it. You think bots are cheap? It’s a numbers game. Every one should be out there over whelming every bot and right wing voice. Everyone should give them no quarter anywhere. The algorithms can only take them so far unless we decided to all of a sudden collectively give up so out spaces at a time that it mattered the most.

    They convinced all of you to leave all the spaces so they could cheaply and effortlessly take over. Now they are infecting every single popular space with only their views and you all pat yourself on the back that you think I’m the idiot for pointing it out. It doesn’t matter if it’s bots or not. They are still more informed and better networked. You are less informed and way less networked. You’re on a website one of the only leftist spaces left that is built to be a snuff box. A website that took every corporate control reddit ever implemented and recreated it. A website that took every mematic theory and built itself purposefully to act like a foil to those ideas. They put all of you in a snuff box.






  • This it what drives me about the left. The average leftist is much less informed about stuff like this than people on the right.

    It’s like people on the left went from being super politically active and informed to casual observer while the right flipped.

    I keep seeing comments like this on leftists spaces where people have no idea what the fuck is going on meanwhile rightwing spaces are 8 layers deep in conspiracy but it’s all based on actual informative stuff that’s happening, it’s just twisted to suit themselves. The left is super cooked even if they start securing wins. People on the left just don’t have the ability to do what past generations could. They don’t like conflict. They want to do disengage and forget about it all during a time when maximum attention is required.




  • Yea really. You can search “couches fucking” and get the same results. It’s yet another story that bots will post to keep you clicking for the hour. You will write “yea fuck Trump he’s such a dick” then I guess up or down vote which are about as real as the tooth fairy but give a sense of something? I guess. Then you move on to the next story.

    This lemmy place is built to keep you just engaged enough. It’s not like 4chan or Facebook or even reddit where a culture is built, investigations and research are done on these things and keeps going day to day by generating new content.

    Lemmy is a place to collect leftist and keep them occupied while the nazis convince your uncle that kids are shitting in cat litter and it’s immigrants fault.

    Look at how they built it. It’s every corporate control reddit implemented for corporate control just ramped up to 11. Why would you all accept that? Leftist use to stand for something, it’s just a vapid and dying culture and most civil action lately has been stuff cooked up by right wing groups to jingle keys like a modern cointelpro