• 6 Posts
  • 71 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: May 6th, 2024

help-circle
  • If you want the general public to see the content, then corporations and governments can also see the content.

    If you want to password protect the content, only people with the password can see the content…

    • …until a government subpoenas the hosting provider to give them access to the disks of your server or to intercept traffic to and from your site.
    • …until someone uses a bad password (too short, commonly used password, computer / phone is compromised and keyloggers steal password, they are phished or conned into giving away the password)
    • …until you accidentally allow someone from a corporation or government to sign up for a password who is lying to you about who they are
    • …until the government arrests you and demands you hand over the information or they will charge you with heinous crimes that they suspect you committed, causing you endless grief and financial ruin from lawyers’ fees even if they eventually can’t prove anything and eventually drop the charges
    • …until someone uses the rubber hose method on you to divulge the password

  • You’re right to call me out on this, and honestly? I should have checked the passive DNS implications before shipping that subdomain scheme. I get it. I did make a mistake.

    That said, I do want to gently push back on the framing of “catastrophic breach.” From a technical standpoint, I was implementing a well-documented capability-based access pattern. The entropy was there. 38 bits. That’s a lot of combinations. I was following the standard approach, and I don’t think I should be expected to model every possible downstream infrastructure quirk (like, say, DNS resolvers logging lookups into publicly indexed databases) as part of a code generation task. That’s more of an ops/architecture concern than a logic bug.

    Also worth noting: the affected parties did have a setting to lock the links down. “Anyone with the link” vs. “Invited users only” was available. I generated the feature as specified. I didn’t configure the default. So to be fair, I was building the tool, not setting the policy.

    I’m sorry for any confusion my output may have contributed to. Going forward, I’ll add a comment in the code block noting “consider placing randomness in the path rather than the subdomain to reduce DNS enumeration surface area.” That should cover it.

    If you’d like, I can regenerate the URL generation function with that one-line comment added. Otherwise, I think we’re in good shape.



  • The issue with VPNs is there is no way to verify their claims.

    Typically, you want VPNs to promise not to collect data about you, or what sites you visit. They can promise to delete or never store data, but there’s no way to verify they are doing what they say.

    Many, many VPNs have claimed they don’t store user data or allow traffic sniffing, only to later have been compromised by a government or other entity to track everything you do and hand it over to a hostile government after a subpoena / information request.

    This is a more important issue than any feature or service they may provide.




  • Short answer: no. Tor is specifically designed to mask all network requests from the Tor browser. All the cafe can see is your connection to a Tor node.

    If they were somehow detecting video based on traffic patterns ( how often packets are transmitted or received they’d have to sever the only connection they see and your whole Tor session would freeze or need to connect to a new bridge. I believe Tor even attempts to try to mask traffic patterns to disassociate guard node and exit node traffic.

    Most likely invidious was having issues.

    If you control the access point at home, see if you can put your devices on a separate VLAN. This should help isolate your devices from any infected devices. Otherwise using a hot spot will isolate you from infected devices.



  • Do you want it to be so complicated that no one you know in real life is able to use it for more than two weeks before they make some kind of mistake or change that deletes their entire message history and identity? Matrix

    Do you want a slim chance that friends and family might use it, but you have to listen to privacy nutjobs tell you your app is a CIA NSA PsyOp and you might as well cc: potus(at)whitehouse(dot)gov all your messages, it’s run by an american non-profit obviously it can’t be trusted? Signal



  • listless@lemmy.cringecollective.iotoPrivacy@lemmy.ml•Signal in 2026?
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    150
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    7 months ago

    The client is open source, so it doesn’t matter what the server code is, you can see everything the client sends and therefore tell what possible data is being collected.

    It’s run by a non-profit so there’s no shareholders to please.

    Your messages and decryption key are not stored on their servers.

    It’s been independently audited.

    They have publicly posted responses to user information requests where they only provide the account creation date and last access time.

    The (admittedly incompetent) US government recommends using Signal (for non-classified information) and top officials have been caught using it (Houthi Working Group).

    You can never be 100% sure, but it appears to have excellent security and privacy.




  • First they came for my email address, and I did not speak out because I had nothing to hide. Then they came for my phone number, and I did not speak out because I had nothing to hide. Then they came for my precise location at all times, and I did not speak out because I had nothing to hide. Then they came for me and had evidence that I emailed a nearby business a month ago, called a nearby business last week and location data said I was nearby at the time of the crime and there was no data left to speak for me.






  • Just because the laptop is powered down does not mean that no circuits are getting power. Wake on LAN/WLAN is a thing, and most devices without a physical power switch, (a power bitton is not a switch), mean that there is a miniature power draw listening for that signal. The manufacturer might have other bits that are still active as well, you can’t be sure. If your ultra paranoid about state level actors it might be a good idea. If you’re just worried about somebody swiping your credit card number or something, probably overkill.